Key challenges of carbon border adjustment mechanism
Carbon leakage occurs when companies move production to countries with mild climate regulations, undermining global efforts to reduce emissions. To address this, the EU introduced the Carbon Border Adjustment Mechanism (CBAM) on Oct. 1, 2023, through Regulation 2023/956. CBAM imposes carbon costs on carbon-intensive imports, creating a more level playing field between EU industries and foreign producers operating under less stringent environmental standards. This mechanism helps combat carbon leakage and promotes global climate policy adoption by ensuring that imported goods face the same carbon costs as goods produced within the EU.
While CBAM has received strong support within the EU and is an important initiative to promote global climate action, it has created several challenges internationally. In a letter to the European Commission, the International Chamber of Commerce (ICC) outlined the challenges companies face under the new regulations:
Access to the CBAM reporting platform
Access to the CBAM reporting platform is complex due to decentralized access protocols that vary by member state. Technical issues, including commodity code errors, have further complicated platform access and usability.
Submission of CBAM reports.
Submitting reports is difficult due to unclear instructions, especially around submission of reports by declarants on behalf of certifying signatories. The platform's limited language options add to the challenge.
High administrative burden
The low de minimis threshold of €150 covers numerous low-volume transactions, increasing compliance costs disproportionately, especially for smaller companies. The requirements also place an unnecessary burden on companies with low-value/weight shipments where a quarterly or simplified reporting option would be beneficial.
Data collection and emissions calculations.
Companies struggle with the complex data requirements and calculation methods for integrated emissions, especially in global supply chains. Existing emission calculation methods can only be used until the end of 2024, so user-friendly guidelines are urgently needed.
Data collection in supply chains.
Importers face difficulties in obtaining required data from different supply chains, especially from non-EU suppliers who may have privacy or data protection concerns, or who are unwilling to disclose certain information. A mechanism for direct access to data by DG TAXUD could help here.
Protection of confidential business information
Sensitive data required in the importer's reporting form may expose confidential business information about production processes that exporters are reluctant to share.
Uncertainty about default values
The limited availability of default values during the transition period complicates reporting. Expanding their use could help with compliance while companies adjust to CBAM requirements.
These challenges highlight the need for streamlined procedures, sound technical support, and clearer guidelines to facilitate CBAM implementation and reduce unnecessary burdens on companies.